Learn

The Closing Report Card: how to calculate closing line value for every bet

Here is how to calculate closing line value for every bet: take both closing prices, remove the margin to get a fair chance, and compare it with the chance your own price needed. In a hypothetical, a bet at -110 that closes at -125 / +105 has a fair closing chance of about 53.25 percent against the 52.38 percent it needed, a CLV of about +1.65 percent, whether the bet won or lost.

Updated October 22, 2026 · 6 min read

The closing report card grades each bet by the price you got, not by whether it won. It is the sheet from our video on closing line value, with the formula and a tracking table you can copy.

The steps from the video, in order:

  1. Take the closing prices. Write down both sides of the market at the close, the last price before the game starts.
  2. Remove the margin. Turn the two closing prices into a fair chance for your side.
  3. Compare it with the chance your price needed. The difference, as a percent of your price's chance, is your closing line value (CLV).

And one caution that goes with every grade: in thin markets like most player props, the close is at best an informed guess, so those grades count for less.

Why grade the price instead of the result

A single bet's result is mostly noise. A bet can be a good price and lose, or a bad price and win. The close is the market's final word on a game, after all the news and money is in, so comparing your price with it tells you whether you were getting better numbers than the market settled on. Data providers describe it the same way: positive CLV means the price you took beat the devigged close.

That is also why sportsbooks pay attention to it. Researchers who used closing-odds probabilities to find mispriced bets reported that bookmakers responded with discriminatory practices against successful clients, which tells you the close is a number books take seriously.

1. Take the closing prices

Record both sides of the exact market you bet (same game, same line) at the moment it closes. If you bet Hawks -110 on the moneyline, you need the closing moneyline on both Hawks and Wolves, not just your side.

Use the sharpest, busiest market you can get for the close. A big, liquid market gives you a close that reflects a lot of money and information. Write the time next to the prices, since some books keep moving right up to the start.

2. Remove the margin

The two closing prices add up to more than 100 percent; the extra is the book's overround, also called the margin or vig. To find the fair chance:

  • Convert each closing price to an implied chance with the standard moneyline conversion: for a negative price, the price (without its sign) divided by the price plus 100; for a positive price, 100 divided by the price plus 100.
  • Add the two chances.
  • Divide your side's chance by the total.

In the video's hypothetical, the close is Hawks -125 and Wolves +105. Using the same conversion, that is 55.56 and 48.78 percent, a total of 104.34 percent, and a fair Hawks chance of 55.56 divided by 104.34, about 53.25 percent.

Unabated's guide to closing line value makes the same point: compare against the no-vig close, because comparing raw prices mixes the book's margin into your grade.

3. Compare and grade

Your bet at -110 needed a 52.38 percent chance to break even (110 divided by 210, from the moneyline conversion). The fair close says 53.25 percent. The formula from Unabated is:

CLV = (fair closing chance minus your price's chance) divided by your price's chance

So (53.25 minus 52.38) divided by 52.38 is about +1.65 percent. That bet gets a good grade even if the Hawks lost.

Now the opposite case, also hypothetical. Same bet at -110, but the game closes at -105 on both sides. The fair close is 50 percent, and the CLV is (50 minus 52.38) divided by 52.38, about -4.55 percent. That bet gets a poor grade even if it won.

The tracking table to copy

One row per bet. All rows below are hypothetical; the math follows the moneyline conversion and the formula above.

Bet Your price Chance needed Close (your side / other side) Fair close CLV Result
Hawks ML (demo) -110 52.38% -125 / +105 53.25% +1.65% Lost
Hawks ML (demo) -110 52.38% -105 / -105 50.00% -4.55% Won
Owls ML (demo) +120 45.45% +110 / -130 45.73% +0.60% Lost
Bears ML (demo) -150 60.00% -165 / +140 59.91% -0.15% Won
Foxes ML (demo) +105 48.78% -102 / -118 48.26% -1.06% Lost

In a spreadsheet with your price in B2 and the two closing prices in D2 and E2, the implied chance of a negative price is =-B2/(-B2+100) and of a positive one =100/(B2+100). The fair close is your side's closing chance divided by the sum of both, and CLV is =(fair-needed)/needed.

Notice the Result column. Two of the three bets with positive CLV lost and both bets with negative CLV won. Over a handful of bets the results tell you very little; the CLV column is the one to watch.

Where the grade misleads

  • Thin markets. Unabated singles out illiquid markets such as the WNBA, early-season college basketball and most player props, where the close is a weaker signal. Grade those bets separately, or not at all.
  • Inefficient markets. The same source warns that positive CLV in an inefficient market can mislead, and calls CLV a guidepost rather than gospel.
  • Using the wrong close. Your book's own close may still carry a big margin. Remove the margin first, and prefer a sharp, busy market as the reference.
  • Mixing lines. If you bet -3 and the market closed at -3.5, you are comparing two different bets. Record the line with every price.

How to tell it's working

Keep the report card for every bet for a few months and look at the average CLV, not the win rate. A consistently positive average across a few hundred bets in liquid markets is a sign your process gets better prices than the market settles on. A negative average means the opposite, even during a winning stretch. Either way, it is a measure of your prices, not a promise about future results.

The closing line value guide explains the idea in more depth, and the CLV calculator runs the formula for any bet.

Quant+ is analytics for informational purposes. Nothing is guaranteed. 21+. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Questions people ask

What is the formula for closing line value?

CLV equals the fair closing chance minus your price's implied chance, divided by your price's implied chance. Use the no-vig close, with the margin removed from both closing prices.

Can a losing bet have positive CLV?

Yes. If you bet -110 and the fair close is 53.25 percent, the bet beat the close by about 1.65 percent even if it lost. CLV grades the price, not the result.

Does CLV work for player props?

Less well. In thin markets such as most player props, the close reflects less money and information, so treat CLV there as a weak signal.

How many bets do I need before average CLV means something?

Track a few hundred bets in liquid markets before reading much into the average. A handful of bets can swing either way.

Sources

  1. Getting precise about closing line value, Unabated
  2. Mathematics of bookmaking, Wikipedia
  3. Moneyline odds, Wikipedia
  4. Closing Line Value (CLV), SharpAPI docs
  5. Beating the bookies with their own numbers, and how the online sports betting market is rigged, arXiv (Kaunitz, Zhong, Kreiner)