Learn
The Reference Price: sharp vs recreational sportsbooks, and how to use the sharp line
Sharp vs recreational sportsbooks price the same game differently, and the Reference Price is a three-step sheet for using that: take the sharp price, take out its small margin, then hold your own book's price against that fair number. In one golf-odds study, blind bets lost about 3 percent at Pinnacle and about 7 at two recreational books, and almost all of the gap was margin. 21+. Nothing is guaranteed.
This is the sheet from the Reference Price video. It has the same three steps in the same order, the study behind them, a blank sheet to copy, and what to keep in mind about the sharp books themselves.
Who it is for: anyone with accounts at one or two recreational books who wants a quick way to tell whether a line is good, fair or poor. You need a sharp book's price on both sides of the market and your own book's price on the side you like.
The three steps
- Sharp price. Take both sides of the market from a sharp book such as Pinnacle or Circa.
- Margin out. Remove the sharp book's margin to get a fair probability.
- Your price against it. Compare your book's price with that fair number.
Why the sharp book is the reference
Data Golf's analysis of golf betting odds found that Pinnacle generally offers odds with the lowest margin, around 3.7 percent. It also measured what happens if you bet every line blind: in golf matchups, a blind bettor lost about 3.31 percent at Pinnacle, 7.08 percent at bet365 and 7.01 percent at DraftKings.
The surprising part is what happens with the margin removed. The same study found margin-free blind returns near zero at all three books, about -0.01, +0.06 and -0.34 percent. So the gap between the books was almost entirely margin, not better or worse lines on the games. And when Data Golf combined closing odds across books, it found the best weight was nearly all on Pinnacle. Those are golf numbers, one sport and one analysis, so treat them as a strong hint rather than a law.
The other half of the reputation is about who the books let bet. Circa Sports is often described as a favourite of sharp bettors, and reporting in the Indiana Business Journal named it that way while citing several large books for limiting professionals. A review of Circa describes high-limit wagers without the restrictions many books use against sharps. Those are reputations and reviews, not audited numbers, which is why the video says "known for".
Step 1, the sharp price
Write down both sides from the sharp book, at the same moment you look at your own book. A price from an hour ago is a different market. In the video's demo, the sharp book has the Hawks and the Owls both at -104.
Step 2, margin out
Convert both sides to implied probabilities. -104 is 104 divided by 204, about 50.98 percent, and the two sides add up to 101.96 percent, about two points over 100. That uses the standard moneyline conversion. Divide each side by the total and you get a fair 50 percent each.
On a thin sharp market the method you use to remove the margin hardly matters. On wider markets it does, and research comparing methods found the power method generally does as well as or better than the simple proportional method.
Step 3, your price against it
Now hold your book's price against the fair number. In the demo, a recreational book at -115 on the Hawks implies about 53.5 percent, worse than the fair 50. A book at -105 is close. A book at +100 implies exactly 50, so it matches the fair price with no margin on your side, which is the best of the three.
| Book (demo) | Your price | Implied | Fair (sharp) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sharp book | -104 / -104 | 50.98% each | 50.0% | reference |
| Book A | -115 | 53.49% | 50.0% | poor |
| Book B | -105 | 51.22% | 50.0% | close |
| Book C | +100 | 50.00% | 50.0% | matches fair |
All prices in the table are demo data for one hypothetical game.
The sheet
Copy this and fill one row per bet you are thinking about.
| Game and side | Sharp price (both sides) | Sharp total | Fair probability | Your book's price | Your implied | Better or worse than fair |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
The fair odds calculator and the devig calculator do the middle columns for you.
Why recreational books still matter
None of this makes recreational books useless. They are where most people actually bet, and they often post promotions, boosts and different lines on props that a sharp book may not offer at all. The point of the reference price is not to move all your betting somewhere else. It is to know, for each bet, whether you are paying a little margin or a lot, and to say no to the second kind more often. Over a season that habit matters more than any single pick.
What to watch out for
- Thin markets. A sharp book's price on a small market moves on little money and is less reliable as a reference.
- Different markets. Compare the same bet type and the same line. A -3 and a -3.5 are different bets.
- Access. Not every sharp book takes bets everywhere. You can still use its price as information.
- Fair is not a forecast of the result. A price at or better than fair can still lose.
How to tell it worked
Over a few weeks, count how many of your bets were at or better than the sharp fair price. If that share goes up, you are paying less margin on every bet you make, whatever the results say in the short run. For the next step, see line shopping and closing line value.
21+. For informational purposes only. Nothing is guaranteed. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between sharp and recreational sportsbooks?
Sharp books keep small margins and are known for taking bets from winners. In one golf-odds study, Pinnacle had the lowest margin, around 3.7 percent, while recreational books carried more.
Why do bettors use Pinnacle as a reference?
Because its prices carry a small margin and track the market closely. Data Golf found the best combined estimate put nearly all of its weight on Pinnacle in golf.
How do I compare my sportsbook's line with Pinnacle's?
Take both sides of Pinnacle's market, convert to probabilities, divide each by their total, and compare your book's implied probability with that fair number.
Does betting at a sharp book mean you will win?
No. A better price means a smaller margin, not a winning bet. Nothing is guaranteed.
Sources
- Analyzing betting odds, Data Golf
- Sportsbooks say you can win big, then they try to limit winners, Indiana Business Journal
- Circa Sports review, Top End Sports
- Adjusting bookmaker's odds to allow for overround, American Journal of Sports Science
- Moneyline odds, Wikipedia
