Learn
The Wind Check: how wind affects NFL totals, and what heat does to MLB
Knowing how wind affects NFL totals matters more than the cold: in one sample of NFL games at 20F or colder the over hit 23 of 40, while the eight with wind over 15 mph landed about 7.5 points under. The Wind Check is two questions before any weather total: how hard is it blowing (and in baseball, how hot is it), and has the total already moved enough? This guide is the one-page chart with the sources. 21+, nothing is guaranteed.
The Wind Check in two questions
The video behind this guide boils weather betting down to two questions, and this page opens with the same two. Ask them in this order before you bet any outdoor total.
- How hard is it blowing, and in baseball, how hot is it? In football, wind is the number that moves scoring, not cold on its own. Covers reports that passing production and efficiency fall as wind rises, and that the drop from 15-20 mph to 20+ mph is about 1.5 to 2 times the size of the earlier steps. In baseball the weather that matters most is heat, because warm air is thinner and the ball carries farther, which a Dartmouth-led study tied to more home runs.
- Has the total already moved enough? Books see the same forecast you do. Spotting the weather is not the edge by itself, so the second question is whether the number has already moved by as much as the conditions justify. Our line movement tool shows every tick from open to now.
Question one in football: why cold alone isn't the under
It's tempting to bet the under every time a game is freezing. The data in one well-known sample says otherwise. In Sharp Football Analysis's look at NFL games played at 20 degrees or colder since 2009, the over hit in 23 of 40 games (58%), with an average closing total of 42.4 and an average of 43.6 points scored.
Inside those same cold games, the eight played with wind over 15 mph tell a different story. The same article lists an average line of 39.25 and an average of 31.75 points, about 7.5 points under the total, with the over hitting 3 of 8. Eight games is a tiny sample, and the authors say so themselves, so read it as a lean that agrees with the passing data, not as a rule.
Why wind and not cold? Wind hits the parts of football that score points through the air. Covers puts the average NFL game wind at about 7 mph and says that at 20+ mph, field goal attempt distance drops by about 7 yards and conversion by about 6%. Shorter kicks and fewer long throws mean drives stall earlier.
Question one in baseball: heat, then wind
Baseball flips the script. The Dartmouth summary of the study, which looked at about 100,000 MLB games and 220,000 batted balls, found that higher temperatures substantially increase home runs. Bloomberg Linea's write-up gives the size: about 1.96% more home runs for every 1 degree Celsius rise in the daily high, and about 2.4% in early-afternoon games. One degree Celsius is 1.8 degrees Fahrenheit, so a 10 degree Fahrenheit swing is about 5.6 degrees Celsius.
Wind in baseball is more park-specific than people think. In The Hardball Times study of 2005-06 games, the league-wide home run per fly ball rate was 14.03% with the wind blowing out and 13.85% blowing in, a gap that was not statistically significant. At Wrigley Field and U.S. Cellular Field the gaps were large and significant. So for baseball wind, the park matters more than the forecast headline.
The one-page Wind Check chart
| Sport | Condition | What the sources show | What to check next |
|---|---|---|---|
| NFL | Cold, 20F or below, light wind | Over 23-40 in one sample, scoring near the total | Don't bet the under on cold alone |
| NFL | Wind 15-20 mph | Passing efficiency falls with each step | Kickers' range, passing-heavy teams |
| NFL | Wind 20+ mph | The steepest drop; FG distance about 7 yards shorter | Has the total already dropped? |
| NFL | Cold plus wind over 15 mph | About 7.5 under the line, but only 8 games | Treat as a lean, check the move |
| MLB | Hot day game | About 2% more home runs per +1C | Has the total risen with the forecast? |
| MLB | Wind out or in | League-wide effect small; big at some parks | Which park, which direction |
Sources for the chart: Covers, Sharp Football Analysis, Bloomberg Linea and The Hardball Times.
How to run the check, step by step
- Get the forecast for game time, not the morning. Look up sustained wind and gusts at kickoff or first pitch, plus the temperature. Skip domes and closed roofs, because the weather doesn't reach the field.
- Place it on the chart. In football, find the wind band. In baseball, note the temperature and, for parks known for wind, the direction.
- Read the move. Compare the opening total with the current one on the line movement tool. A hypothetical example: a total that opened at 41.5 and now sits at 39.5 has already moved two points for the forecast.
- Ask whether the move matches the conditions. If the wind is at the top of the chart and the total hasn't moved, that is worth a closer look. If it has already dropped a lot, the weather may be fully priced.
- Price the side you like. Use the no-vig calculator to see the fair price of the over and under before you bet. Weather is one input, and the price still decides whether a bet is worth it.
What to watch out for
Small samples. The cold-and-wind numbers above come from 40 games and a subset of 8. Sharp Football Analysis itself calls the subsets small and notes older data is less relevant. Use them to understand direction, not size.
Forecasts change. Wind forecasts a day out can be off by a lot. Check again close to the game, and don't assume the move you see was caused by weather; injuries and other news move totals too.
Books price weather. This is the whole point of question two. Everyone can read a forecast, so the edge, if there is one, is in a number that hasn't caught up yet.
How to tell it's working
Log every weather total you bet in a bet tracker with the wind, the temperature and the total you got. Then compare your number with the closing total using the closing line value calculator. If you're beating the close on weather bets over a long run, the check is doing its job. If you're not, the market was already ahead of the forecast, and that's useful to know too. Results on a handful of games prove very little either way.
21+. For informational purposes only. Nothing is guaranteed. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit the National Council on Problem Gambling.
Questions people ask
Does cold weather make NFL games go under?
Not on its own. In one sample of NFL games at 20F or colder since 2009, the over hit 23 of 40. Wind is the factor tied to lower scoring.
How much wind matters for an NFL total?
Covers reports passing falls as wind rises, with the steepest drop past 20 mph, where field goal distance falls about 7 yards. Check the forecast at kickoff and whether the total has moved.
Does heat really add home runs?
A study of about 100,000 MLB games found about 2% more home runs per 1 degree Celsius rise in the daily high, because warm air is thinner.
Is betting the weather an edge?
Only if the total hasn't already moved for it. Books read the same forecast, so compare the open and current numbers before you bet.
Sources
- How weather affects betting, Covers
- Cold weather impact on NFL over/unders, Sharp Football Analysis
- Climate crisis causing more home runs in baseball, Dartmouth
- There are more home runs in baseball thanks to climate change, Bloomberg Linea
- When the wind blows, The Hardball Times
- National Council on Problem Gambling, NCPG
