Learn

The Prop Margin Check: player prop vig, fair odds and both devig methods side by side

Player prop vig is the reason props are harder to beat than moneylines, and the Prop Margin Check is a three-step worksheet for any prop, at BetMGM or anywhere else. Measure the margin, remove it two ways, and make sure you're comparing the same line. This page has the panel data behind the video, the steps, a worksheet with both devig methods side by side, and the hypothetical where the method flips the answer.

Updated October 21, 2026 · 6 min read

This is the worksheet from the video, in the video's order.

The check in three moves:

  1. Props carry more margin. In one panel of 52 sportsbooks, props averaged about 7.9 percent margin, against 4.8 on moneylines.
  2. Remove the margin, then match the line. Take both sides of the prop and strip the margin, then make sure the other price you compare is for the same number, because over 24.5 and over 25.5 are different bets.
  3. The method matters. On a hypothetical prop at -250 and +190, the multiplicative method calls an over at -215 a loser and the power method calls it a winner.

All prices on this page are demo or hypothetical, not any sportsbook's actual line.

How big the prop margin is

The Bookmaker Margin Panel, a dataset published on Mendeley Data in 2026, tracks margins across 52 bookmakers from late June to early August 2026. It reports an average margin of 7.93 percent on 699,733 two-sided player prop markets, against 4.77 percent on head-to-head (moneyline) markets, 4.90 percent on spreads and 5.45 percent on totals. It is a dataset description rather than a peer-reviewed study, but the gap is large and the sample is big.

What that means in practice: a prop's price has to sit further from fair before it becomes a good bet, because you start further behind. A three-point bigger margin on a two-sided market is roughly a point and a half more cost on each side.

Step 1, measure the margin on the prop

Convert both sides to implied chances with the standard moneyline rules: for a negative price, the price over the price plus 100; for a positive price, 100 over the price plus 100. Add them up. Anything over 100 percent is margin.

Demo prop Over Under Total Margin
Points 24.5 at -115 / -115 53.49% 53.49% 106.98% 6.98 pts
Points 24.5 at -125 / +100 55.56% 50.00% 105.56% 5.56 pts
Hypothetical at -250 / +190 71.43% 34.48% 105.91% 5.91 pts

Step 2, remove it two ways

Multiplicative: divide each implied chance by the total. Power: raise both implied chances to the same exponent k, chosen so they add up to exactly 1. Power takes more of the margin off the long side. In a 2017 comparison, Clarke, Kovalchik and Ingram found the power method universally outperformed multiplicative and was better than or comparable to the Shin method.

Step 3, match the line

Before you compare a fair price with another book's price, check the number. A fair chance for over 24.5 says nothing directly about over 25.5. The half point between them is a real outcome (exactly 25), and on a stat like points it can be a common one. Compare only identical lines, or treat alternate lines as their own markets.

The worksheet, both methods side by side

Expected value per $100 is the fair win chance times the profit minus the fair lose chance times 100. Here is the worksheet filled in for three hypothetical props, each with an over offered at another book:

Hypothetical market Over offered at Multiplicative fair over EV per $100 (multiplicative) Power fair over EV per $100 (power)
-125 / +100 -105 52.63% +$2.76 52.85% +$3.19
-140 / +110 -120 55.06% +$0.94 55.52% +$1.78
-250 / +190 -215 67.44% -$1.19 69.04% +$1.15

On close-to-even props the two methods agree on the verdict and only the size changes. On the lopsided one, the verdict flips. That is the case to watch: when the two methods disagree on the sign, the edge is too thin to trust without a better fair price.

Copy these columns for your own props:

  1. Prop, player, stat and line
  2. Over and under prices at the reference book, converted with the moneyline rules
  3. Implied over, implied under, total
  4. Multiplicative fair over = implied over / total
  5. Power fair over (solve for k so both sides raised to k sum to 1)
  6. Offered price at the other book, same line only
  7. EV per $100 under each method
  8. Verdict: bet only if both methods agree it is positive

What to watch out for

  • Thin reference markets. A prop with little betting behind it gives a weaker fair price than a main moneyline.
  • Line mismatches. The most common error in prop comparisons is comparing 24.5 with 25.5.
  • Limits. Prop bettors who win get noticed. A 2022 Washington Post report, republished by the Indianapolis Business Journal, quoted bettors describing sharp cuts to how much they could stake at BetMGM and other books once they were winning. Researchers who used public odds to find mispriced bets reported similar treatment of successful clients.
  • Variance. A positive-EV prop still loses often. The over in the last row loses about 31 percent of the time even if the power price is right.

How to tell it worked

Fill the worksheet for the three hypothetical props above and check that your numbers match. On real props, keep a log of the fair price you used, the method, and the closing price. If your positive-EV props keep closing at worse prices than you got, your process is finding real gaps. If they don't, the margin is probably eating the edge.

See the BetMGM positive EV bets page for how this applies to one book, and the devig calculator for both methods without the arithmetic. The Quant+ board shows each line's de-vigged fair value and edge, with power as the default method.

Quant+ is analytics for informational purposes. 21+. Nothing is guaranteed. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Questions people ask

Why is the vig higher on player props?

Props are smaller, harder-to-price markets, and books build in more margin. In one 52-book panel, props averaged about 7.9 percent margin against 4.8 percent on moneylines.

Which devig method should I use for props?

Compare two. On close-to-even props multiplicative and power agree; on lopsided ones power usually gives the favorite side a higher fair chance. If they disagree on whether a bet is positive, the edge is too thin to trust.

Can I compare over 24.5 at one book with over 25.5 at another?

Not directly. They are different bets, because a result of exactly 25 wins one and loses the other. Compare only the same line.

Are BetMGM props worse than other books' props?

This page doesn't claim that. The panel figures are averages across 52 bookmakers. Check each prop's own margin with the worksheet.

Sources

  1. Bookmaker Margin Panel, Mendeley Data (E. Glush)
  2. Moneyline odds, Wikipedia
  3. Expected value, Wikipedia
  4. Adjusting bookmaker's odds to allow for overround, American Journal of Sports Science
  5. Sportsbooks say you can win big, then they try to limit winners, IBJ (Washington Post)
  6. Beating the bookies with their own numbers, arXiv (Kaunitz, Zhong, Kreiner)