Learn

The Three Method Check: how to devig odds with all three standard formulas

Here is how to devig odds three ways, and why the Three Method Check matters: multiplicative, additive and power can give three different fair prices for the same favorite. This sheet has the formula for each method, the worked example from the video at -1000 and +650, two more markets to practice on, and a short guide to which method to trust when they disagree.

Updated October 21, 2026 · 6 min read

This is the sheet from the video. It keeps the same order: the market, then the three methods, then the gap between them.

The video in four lines:

  1. The market. A hypothetical favorite at -1000 and underdog at +650. Their implied chances add up to more than 100, and the extra is the book's margin.
  2. Multiplicative shrinks both sides by the same share and calls the favorite fair at -682.
  3. Additive takes the same number of points off each side and says -792.
  4. Power raises both chances to the same power until they add up to 100, so the long shot loses more, and the favorite comes out at -878. A 2017 study backs power over multiplicative.

Step 1, turn each price into an implied chance

For a negative American price, the implied chance is the price divided by the price plus 100. For a positive price, it is 100 divided by the price plus 100. Both rules come straight from the moneyline odds conversion, which also notes that the quoted chances of all outcomes adding up to more than 100 percent is how a balanced book makes its profit.

For the video's market:

  • Favorite -1000: 1000 / 1100 = 90.91 percent
  • Underdog +650: 100 / 750 = 13.33 percent
  • Total: 104.24 percent, so the margin is 4.24 points

Removing the margin means shrinking those two numbers until they add up to exactly 100. The three methods disagree on how to share the cut.

Step 2, the three formulas

Multiplicative (also called proportional or normalized). Divide each implied chance by the total.

fair = implied / total

90.91 / 104.24 gives a fair favorite of 87.21 percent, or -682.

Additive. Take the same number of points off every outcome: the margin divided by the number of outcomes.

fair = implied - (total - 100) / n

With two outcomes, each loses 2.12 points, so the favorite is 88.79 percent, or -792.

Power. Find the one exponent k that makes the implied chances, each raised to k, add up to exactly 1. Then use the raised numbers.

fair = implied ^ k, with k chosen so the fair chances sum to 1

Here k is about 1.1317, and the favorite comes out at 89.77 percent, or -878. Because raising a small number to a power above 1 shrinks it proportionally more than a big one, power takes more of the margin off the long shot. You need a solver or a few lines of code to find k, which is why calculators do it for you.

The worked examples

All three markets below are hypothetical, so you can check your own calculator against them.

Market (hypothetical) Implied total Multiplicative fair favorite Additive fair favorite Power fair favorite
-1000 / +650 104.24% 87.21% (-682) 88.79% (-792) 89.77% (-878)
-200 / +170 103.70% 64.29% (-180) 64.81% (-184) 65.08% (-186)
-150 / +130 103.48% 57.98% (-138) 58.26% (-140) 58.40% (-140)
-110 / -110 104.76% 50.00% (+100) 50.00% (+100) 50.00% (+100)

The pattern is the point of the sheet. On an even market the methods agree. The further apart the two sides are, the more they disagree, and on a heavy favorite the gap between multiplicative and power is more than two and a half points of probability.

Which method to trust

Clarke, Kovalchik and Ingram compared the additive, multiplicative, Shin and power methods for removing the overround in 2017. They found the power method universally outperformed the multiplicative method and was better than or comparable to Shin's method. That is the reason many tools default to power, and it is the default on the Quant+ board.

A practical rule:

  1. Close to even markets: any method is fine, the answers are nearly identical.
  2. Favorites and long shots: use power, or at least compare power with multiplicative before you call something an edge.
  3. Three-way and futures markets: avoid additive. Taking equal points off every outcome can push a long shot near or below zero, which is plain arithmetic, not a fair chance.

Why the method changes your edge

Your edge is your price against the fair price, so a fair price that moves by two points moves every edge with it. Say, as an example, a second book offers the -1000 favorite at -700. Against the multiplicative fair of -682 it looks slightly bad. Against the power fair of -878 it looks clearly good. Same bet, same market, opposite answers, only because of the method. Check the method before you check the edge.

The market itself also matters. Bookmakers tend to set a price and adjust it infrequently, so a fair price from one book's market is only as current as its last move. And betting odds are hard to beat as forecasts: a PLOS ONE paper notes they frequently outperform mathematical models. Devigging a sharp market is usually the best fair price you can get without a model.

The sheet

Copy this into a spreadsheet, one row per market:

  1. Price A, price B (American).
  2. Implied A and B with the conversion rules above.
  3. Total = implied A + implied B.
  4. Multiplicative A = implied A / total.
  5. Additive A = implied A - (total - 1) / 2.
  6. Power: solve k so implied A ^ k + implied B ^ k = 1 (Goal Seek in Excel or Sheets works), then power A = implied A ^ k.
  7. Convert each fair chance back to American odds to compare with other books.

How to tell it worked

Run the four hypothetical markets in the table through your sheet or your calculator. If you match all twelve fair prices, your setup is right. If a calculator gives one answer and doesn't say which method it used, you now know how to find out: compare its number with the three columns.

Try it on the devig calculator, then use the fair odds calculator and the positive EV betting guide to turn a fair price into an edge.

Quant+ is analytics for informational purposes. 21+. Nothing is guaranteed. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Questions people ask

What does devig mean?

Devigging removes the sportsbook's margin from its prices so the implied chances add up to 100 percent. What is left is an estimate of the fair chance of each outcome.

Which devig method is most accurate?

A 2017 comparison by Clarke, Kovalchik and Ingram found the power method universally outperformed the multiplicative method and was better than or comparable to the Shin method. On close to even markets the methods give nearly the same answer.

Why do devig calculators give different fair odds?

Because they use different methods to share out the margin. Multiplicative cuts both sides by the same share, additive by the same points, and power takes more from the long shot, so the answers split most on heavy favorites.

Can I devig a three-way market like soccer?

Yes. Multiplicative and power both work with any number of outcomes. Be careful with additive, because equal point cuts can make a long shot's fair chance unrealistically small.

Sources

  1. Adjusting bookmaker's odds to allow for overround, American Journal of Sports Science (Clarke, Kovalchik, Ingram)
  2. Moneyline odds, Wikipedia
  3. Why are gambling markets organised so differently from financial markets?, Economic Journal via RePEc (Levitt)
  4. The Betting Odds Rating System, PLOS ONE